Red Dead Redemption 2's Saint Denis Theater Mystery Explained (2024)

One of the biggest things that make Red Dead Redemption 2 a good game is what seems to be an endless number of secrets that are waiting to be discovered by players. Although the game has been released for about two years now, fans are still uncovering mysteries, some of which remain unsolved today.

Now, adding to the long list of Red Dead Redemption 2 mysteries is a relatively new secret that can be found within the halls of the Saint-Denis theater. It is worth noting that this particular mystery is fairly difficult to uncover given that players must perform specific actions in order to trigger the events leading to the secret.

RELATED: Red Dead Online Halloween Event Leaks Months Ahead of Time

How to Trigger the Saint-Denis Theater Mystery

Upon entering the theater in the city of Saint-Denis, players can purchase a ticket to see a vaudeville type of performances playing in the venue. To trigger the secret, severalfans revealed that players must visit the theater several times. Moreover, it is advisable that before embarking on this quest, players must first complete The Smell of the Grease Paint side mission in the game, which revolves around Arthur helping a woman named Marjorie, who is traveling the world to perform with hertroupe. Now, it is currently unclear whether completing this side quest is mandatory to trigger the secret. However, several players revealed that it only worked after completing this particular quest.

After completing the quest, players must head into the Saint-Denis theater, purchase a ticket, and watch all of the performances. It is worth knowing that the performances in the theater would take about half an hour to complete, given thatthe show consists ofseveral groups giving out different performances. Of course, while it may take a little bit of time to see the entire show, the performances are quite entertaining and is a testament to how Rockstar Games went to all the trouble into putting all these small details in the game.

The show will consist of several acts that include singers, dancers, some mysterious performances, and a magician whose act won't go as planned prompting the player to step in and save the day.After the performances, the show's host would appear on stage to close the event, and it is at this point that the lights would go dim, before coming back on again. At this point,several people from the audience would begin leaving the theater and the curtains on stage would open slightly.

What is the Saint-Denis Theater Mystery?

Red Dead Redemption 2's Saint Denis Theater Mystery Explained (1)

This isArthur's cue to go up the stage and enter the slightly opened curtains. Entering the backstage would trigger the start of the mysterious events, and players would immediately hear some instruments playing within. However, upon checking the backstage, players will see several instruments lying around, but there are no people there. Interestingly enough, if the player looks out to the stage, they will see that there are still some people left inside the theater.

On the other side of the stage, players will see a dimly lit table and if players check it out, they will obtain a cigarette card. Now upon obtaining the card, a weird 'ta-da' sound would play, and upon checking the theater, the people that were just there have mysteriously disappeared. It is worth noting that the amount of time that has passed between obtaining the card and heading back to the theater is only mere seconds, which makes it mysterious as to how those people got out of the theater instantly.

Interestingly enough, the cigarette card reveals a photo of Robin Koninsky, who is one of the singers that just performed inside the theater. It is currently a mystery whether the person featured in the card has something to do with the weird disappearance of the audience. It is also currently unknown what the relevance of the secret is and howthe audience left in the theatercould simply vanish in a short amount of time.

Some speculate that the Saint-Denis theater could be an intricate puzzle that is still unsolved in Red Dead Redemption 2. Other fans even suggested that maybe opening some drawers backstage in a particular sequence would trigger another mystery event, but so far, it appears that no one has been successful in solving this mystery. Asof the moment, it appears that this relatively new mystery discovered in Red Dead Redemption 2's Saint-Denis theater, remains unsolved.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is out now for the PC, PS4, Stadia, and Xbox One.

MORE: Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto Connections Go Deeper Than You Think

  • GR Originals
  • Red Dead Redemption 2
  • PC Gaming

Your changes have been saved

Email Is sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

Manage Your List

Follow

Followed

Follow with Notifications

Follow

Unfollow

Red Dead Redemption 2's Saint Denis Theater Mystery Explained (2024)

FAQs

What happens if you stay at the theater with Mary RDR2? ›

If you go to the theater, you enjoy the theater scene before heading to the trolley ending scene. If you decline going to the theater, they go straight to the trolley ending scene below, with no negative impact on the dialogue or Arthur and Mary's relationship.

Is there anything in the cemetery in Saint Denis rdr2? ›

Examine the wall next to the only wooden crate in the passageway. Final Treasure: The treasure is located in the Saint Denis cemetery. It's stashed inside the mausoleum with a stained-glass window, to the west of the central dome. Head inside and inspect the wall on your left.

How long is the theatre with Mary? ›

After completing the quest, players must head into the Saint-Denis theater, purchase a ticket, and watch all of the performances. It is worth knowing that the performances in the theater would take about half an hour to complete, given that the show consists of several groups giving out different performances.

Where is the Theatre Raleur in Saint Denis? ›

Théâtre Râleur is a theater in Saint Denis featured in Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Online, in the Bayou Nwa region of the Lemoyne territory.

Can Arthur and Mary get together? ›

She loved Arthur and desired to have a life with him, even retaining feelings for him over the years. However, she acknowledges that Arthur's preference for his criminal lifestyle would prevent them from ever having a future together, eventually coming to terms with it and deciding to cut ties with him.

What is the saddest ending in RDR2? ›

Arthur Morgan Dies At The End Of Red Dead Redemption 2

However, the game is finished with possibly the biggest emotional blow of all, as Arthur Morgan dies in the final act. Arthur is the game's protagonist, the character who the player has been controlling since the beginning.

Is there a ghost in the Saint Denis cemetery? ›

One of the spookiest mysteries in Red Dead Redemption 2 occurs in the Saint Denis cemetery, where players can see a ghost woman running away and disappearing into thin air. The reasons this was included in the game by Rockstar, as well as the original intended purpose of the character, have been uncovered by fans.

What happens if you visit all graves in rdr2? ›

There are nine graves in total. The player will have the opportunity to interact with these graves at any time after they become available. The player must interact with all nine graves in order to earn the "Paying Respects" trophy.

Where is the killers hiding place in rdr2? ›

Open your Satchel and open it up. On the back is a sinister message but the image on the front is pointing towards a new location on the map and a combination to open whatever you find there. That location is back up towards Valentine at a place called Lucky's cabin (it's just south of Valentine on the map).

Can you marry Mary in Red Dead Redemption 2? ›

The player has the option to go with her or refuse her offer. If Mary's request is accepted, they buy tickets into the theater and watch a number of acts. After this, the two make their way to the trolley station, where Mary asks Arthur to elope with her.

Does Arthur get back with Mary in RDR2? ›

Mary's younger brother, Jamie, still likes Arthur regardless of his criminal escapades with the Van der Linde gang. Mary eventually marries a man named Barry Linton, but he dies leaving her a poor widow. Though Mary and Arthur cross paths again later in life, they never rekindle their romance again.

Does Mary visit Arthur's grave? ›

and there's one where you see mary visiting. arthur's gravestone.

Can you save Lenny in Saint Denis? ›

During the Saint Denis bank robbery, Lenny Summers loses his life alongside Hosea Matthews. Unlike in franchises like Mass Effect, there's nothing you can do about either of these deaths - officially anyway. Lenny and Hosea have to die, with the gang subsequently ending up in Guarma.

How to get a cigarette card in Saint Denis Theater? ›

After watching all five performances (all set over five nights), you will find this card sitting on top of a table on the left side of the stage inside the Saint Denis Theatre Raleur . When you have watched performances sufficient to get the card, the curtains will open halfway up at the end of the show.

Which room is Lenny in rdr2? ›

Search the saloon for Lenny. If you talk to the bartender, he'll tell you Lenny went upstairs. If you open the door to 1A, you'll get to see a couple going at it… but to find Lenny, just head to the back of the upstairs - opposite of the stairs - he's leaning against the railing, drinking.

Is it worth helping Mary in RDR2? ›

Mary sends Arthur a letter asking for his help to get her brother back. You can choose to help, or part ways with Mary for good. Should you choose to help her, you save her brother and get another mission further along in the story (as well as a date with her), adding more emotional depth to Arthur and his account.

Can you leave with Mary in Red Dead Redemption 2? ›

The player has the option to go with her or refuse her offer. If Mary's request is accepted, they buy tickets into the theater and watch a number of acts. After this, the two make their way to the trolley station, where Mary asks Arthur to elope with her.

Does Arthur give Mary's ring to John? ›

An important detail in the letter is that Mary gives Arthur her blessing to pass the ring on to another couple, which explains why he gives the ring to John before the Marston family flees town after the Van der Linde gang disbands.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Golda Nolan II

Last Updated:

Views: 6298

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Golda Nolan II

Birthday: 1998-05-14

Address: Suite 369 9754 Roberts Pines, West Benitaburgh, NM 69180-7958

Phone: +522993866487

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Shopping, Quilting, Cooking, Homebrewing, Leather crafting, Pet

Introduction: My name is Golda Nolan II, I am a thoughtful, clever, cute, jolly, brave, powerful, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.